|

|

the second club


the second club

Russell D & Associates

The Performance Brief

Edition No. 013 · October 2026

The second club is paid for by the first

Owners worry the new site will steal members. The bigger bill lands somewhere else, on a calendar most owners never see coming.

5 minute read · For club owners, operators and franchisees

The offer usually arrives just as club one starts to feel easy. A landlord with an empty unit, a franchisor with a territory to fill, a member who knows a building. The numbers look good, the team looks settled, and the owner signs.

What follows runs to a calendar. Every step looks sensible on the day it happens, which is why so few owners see the bill coming. Here it is, stage by stage, with what the evidence says at each one.

Month 0 · The fear that gets all the attention

Before signing, most owners worry about the map. Will the new site eat the old one’s members? The best long-run evidence says the effect is real and modest. Arturs Kalnins of Cornell followed ten years of revenue at 1,315 Texas hotels. When a same-brand franchised hotel opened close by, the existing one lost about 2.7 dollars in every 100 of revenue.

Hotels are not gyms, so read that as a direction, not a forecast. The direction is still useful. The cost exists, and it is small enough that the map is rarely what breaks a second club.

Week 2 · Picking the site

That does not mean club two can go anywhere. The IHRSA Health Club Business Handbook puts a club’s primary trading area at about eight minutes’ travel and the secondary at twelve, with the large majority of members drawn from inside that ring. Owners writing in Athletic Business report the same window from their own floors.

Regulars live closer still. Location data from 7.5 million phones, analysed by Dstillery and reported by the Wall Street Journal, found that people who went to the gym about once a month lived a median 5.1 miles (about 8 km) away. The most frequent visitors lived 3.7 miles (about 6 km) away.

That gives you two lines on a map. Put club two outside club one’s twelve minute ring, so you add members instead of moving them. Keep it inside the distance you can drive in a morning, for a reason the next stage makes clear.

Week 6 · Club one goes quiet

By now the owner’s car knows the way to the fit-out better than the way to club one. Nothing breaks. The front desk stops chasing lapsed members because nobody asks about it any more. A sales follow-up slips a day. A cleaning standard drifts.

Franchisors plan for exactly this. Kalnins and Francine Lafontaine looked at every new restaurant opened in Texas between 1980 and 1995 by seven of the largest fast-food chains. The franchisees most likely to be given the next unit were the ones whose existing units sat closest to it. Their reading was that chains protect the cost of supervision. An owner who can drive between sites in a morning keeps both honest.

The members are not the main thing at stake in club two. The owner’s attention is, and club one pays for it first.

Month 4 · The bill arrives

Here is some illustrative arithmetic, not data. A club billing USD 40,000 a month that slips 5 in 100 while you build club two gives up USD 2,000 a month. Across a four-month fit-out that is about USD 8,000.

Then the duty manager you promoted early to run the new site decides the job is bigger than the pay, and the cost stops being a line on a report.

What changes the ending

The owners who avoid this find out whether club one runs without them before they sign, not after. Call it the Empty Chair Test. Spend 14 days away from club one. No visits, no daily calls, one weekly report from your manager. Then compare four numbers with the 14 days before you left.

NumberWhat a slip usually points to
New joinsSales follow-up depends on you being in the building
CancellationsNobody is catching members before they leave
Secondary revenue such as PTCoaches sell harder when someone is watching the diary
Staff absenceThe standard is your presence, not a system

If the numbers hold, club one has a manager and you are ready to look at sites. If they slip, you have found the price of club two while it is still free to find out.

One question before you sign

If you left tomorrow for two weeks, which of those four numbers would move first? Your answer is the job description for the manager you need before club two, and it is far cheaper to write now than in month four.

Over to you. Would club one hold its numbers for 14 days without you?

Take the Performance Diagnostic Find where your club leaks before you open the next one.

References

The figures above are these sources in plain terms. Sample sizes and distances are as the researchers or reporters gave them.

  1. Kalnins, A. (2004). An empirical analysis of territorial encroachment within franchised and company-owned branded chains. Marketing Science 23(4), 476 to 489. Cornell release (2005). Average revenue loss of 2.7% when a same-brand franchised hotel opens nearby, across 1,315 hotels and ten years of Texas data.
  2. Kalnins, A. and Lafontaine, F. (2004). Multi-unit ownership in franchising: evidence from the fast-food industry in Texas. RAND Journal of Economics 35(4), 747 to 761.
  3. McCarthy, J. IHRSA Health Club Business Handbook, chapter on calculating club demand. Primary trading area about 8 minutes, secondary about 12 minutes.
  4. Dstillery mobile location analysis of 7.5 million devices, reported by the Wall Street Journal and summarised by Inc. and Esquire. Median home distance 5.1 miles for about-monthly visitors, 3.7 miles for the most frequent.

Russell D & Associates

Executive Coaching & Consultancy

The Performance Brief is a weekly letter from Russell D & Associates for people who run clubs, teams and businesses.

www.russelldassociates.com


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *