|

,

|

Would your team mark it green?


Would your team mark it green?
Russell D & Associates

Russell D & Associates

The Performance Brief

PB-016

Would Your Team Mark It Green?

A seven-question field test for the distance between what you see from the top and what your team lives with.

The Performance Brief · PB-016 · November 2026 · 6 min read

Nearly nine in ten chief executives believe their people trust them. Fewer than half of their people agree.

That split comes from the second edition of BCG’s CEO Insomnia Index, published in October. Close to 90 in 100 CEOs said they were confident their employees trusted their leadership. Only 46 in 100 employees said they did. Ask about well-being and the picture is no better. Around 70 in 100 CEOs believe staff trust them to protect well-being when money gets tight. Just 36 in 100 staff agree.

46 in 100

employees who say they trust their CEO’s leadership. Close to 90 in 100 CEOs believe the number is far higher.

Nobody in that survey is lying. They are looking at the same business from different floors.

Why the view from the top flatters itself

Bad news travels up through people who are rewarded for good news. Each layer smooths it a little. Project managers have a name for the result, the watermelon report. Green on the outside, red the moment you cut into it.

An AI rollout makes the skin thicker, and most clubs are in the middle of one. CRM automations, chatbot enquiry handling, AI-written programmes and auto-scheduling all arrived in the last two years. BCG’s AI at Work survey, published in June with 11,749 respondents across 14 markets, found that 74 in 100 frontline staff now use AI regularly. Of those regular users, 42 in 100 say it saves them a full working day each week.

Then the catch. 66 in 100 get limited or no guidance on what to do with the time it frees, and more than half say that time does not go into more valuable work. Nearly half of everyone surveyed now spends more time directing and checking the AI than doing the task it was meant to take over.

So the owner sees hours saved on a slide. The front desk sees one more system to supervise.

One honest limit. BCG’s frontline sample is office staff without management duties, not gym floors. Read these numbers as the direction of travel, not a measurement of your club.

Where the gap shows up on your P&L

Trust shows up as effort. In the same BCG index, half of the employees whose trust in their CEO’s handling of AI had risen said they were more willing to go above and beyond than three months earlier. Among those whose trust had fallen, fewer than 10 in 100 said the same.

In a club, going above and beyond is the front desk calling a regular who has not checked in for three weeks. It is the coach who stays ten minutes to fix a new member’s programme. None of it sits in a job description, and all of it sits in your retention figures.

A separate study by BCG and Columbia Business School, 1,399 people surveyed in August 2025, found the same blind spot from another angle. 75 in 100 executives described their company as employee-centric. 23 in 100 individual contributors agreed. The organisations that really were employee-centric were seven times more likely to have reached maturity with AI, and their people were 36% more likely to still be working there a year later.

In a business where a departing coach can walk out with a client book, that last figure is worth more than any software licence.

The field test

You cannot see the gap from where you sit. That is what makes it a gap. You can test for it.

Score each statement. 2 if it is true and you could prove it. 1 if it is partly true, or true on a good week. 0 if it is false or you do not know. Not knowing scores zero on purpose.

  1. 1
    You heard bad news directly from someone two levels below you in the last month.Not through their manager and not in a summary. If every problem reaches you pre-processed, you are reading the skin of the watermelon.
    0 1 2
  2. 2
    Your front-line team could say in one sentence why the last new system was introduced.DHR Global’s 2026 workforce survey found only 34 in 100 employees say their organisation has clearly explained what AI means for their role. If the reason lives only in your head, the team will invent one.
    0 1 2
  3. 3
    Someone has decided where the time saved by a new tool should go.Training, member follow-up calls, an earlier finish or a new service. Any answer beats none. Without a decision, saved hours drift into busywork.
    0 1 2
  4. 4
    You track what a new system costs your team in checking and fixing, as well as what it saves.Vendors report the saving. Nobody reports the hour a day spent correcting auto-generated programmes or chasing a chatbot’s wrong answer.
    0 1 2
  5. 5
    Your managers get credit for raising a problem early, not only for reporting green.If amber costs a manager standing, you will only ever see green.
    0 1 2
  6. 6
    Your most junior team member could disagree with you in a meeting without it costing them.Ask yourself when it last happened. If you cannot remember, that is your answer.
    0 1 2
  7. 7
    Your read on team trust comes from the team, not from your managers’ read of the team.An anonymous two-question pulse, a stay interview or a coffee with the newest hire will do. Second-hand trust data is the watermelon again.
    0 1 2
ScoreWhat it means
12 to 14The gap is narrow and you probably know where it is. Keep the habits that got you here.
7 to 11The common result. Your dashboard is telling part of the story, and your zeros show which part is missing.
0 to 6You are working from a filtered version of your own business. Every fix on this list costs a conversation, not a budget.

Score it twice

Your own score is half the test. Print a blank copy and hand it to the most junior person you trust to be straight with you. Ask them to score you, anonymously if that makes it easier.

The difference between the two totals is your perception gap, measured in your own building. Start with the item where you disagree most.

Take the test with your team

Download the free Perception Gap Field Test. It has your score sheet, an anonymous team copy worded from their side, and a page that turns the two totals into your gap with a first move for each item.

Download the free field test

References

The figures above are translated from these sources. Percentages are written as people in 100.

  1. Boston Consulting Group (2026). CEO Insomnia Index, second edition. Press release, 14 October 2026. 87% of CEOs confident employees trust their leadership vs 46% of employees. Close to 70% of CEOs vs 36% of employees on well-being. 50% vs under 10% more willing to go above and beyond, by direction of trust change.
  2. Boston Consulting Group (2026). AI at Work 2026: Strategy Matters More Than Tools. June 2026, n = 11,749, 14 markets. Frontline = individual white-collar employees with no managerial responsibilities. 74% regular AI use. 42% of regular frontline users save at least 8 hours a week. 66% limited or no guidance on time saved. 47% spend more time managing AI than doing the work.
  3. Lovich, D., Meier, S. and Taylor, C. (2025). Leaders Assume Employees Are Excited About AI. They’re Wrong. Harvard Business Review, November 2025. BCG Henderson Institute and Columbia Business School survey, August 2025, n = 1,399. 75% of executives vs 23% of individual contributors on employee-centricity. Employee-centric organisations 7x more likely to be AI mature. Employees 36% more likely to remain one year later.
  4. DHR Global (2025). Workforce Trends Report 2026. 34% of employees say their organisation has communicated very clearly what AI means for their role.

Russell

Russell D & Associates

Executive Coaching & Consultancy

The Performance Brief is a weekly letter from Russell D & Associates for people who run clubs, teams and businesses.

russelldassociates.com


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *