|

,

|

Calm on the outside


Calm on the outside
Russell D & Associates

Russell D & Associates

The Performance Brief

PB-017

Calm on the Outside

There are two ways to keep your composure when the pressure lands. One of them costs you part of the conversation and sends the other person a share of the bill.

The Performance Brief · PB-017 · November 2026 · 6 min read

At 3.27 on a January afternoon in 2009, a flock of Canada geese took out both engines of US Airways Flight 1549 over New York. The aircraft was below 3,000 feet with 155 people on board, and it had just become a glider.

Captain Chesley Sullenberger took the controls. His first officer opened the engine restart checklist. About three and a half minutes later the aircraft was floating on the Hudson River and every person on it was alive.

On the air traffic tapes his voice hardly moves. “We’re gonna be in the Hudson,” he says, in the tone most of us use to order a coffee.

Weeks later he told CBS what those minutes had felt like from the inside. He called it “the worst sickening pit of your stomach, falling through the floor feeling” he had ever had.

“Calm on the outside, turmoil on the inside.”

Captain Chesley Sullenberger, to ESPN, February 2009

So one of the most admired displays of calm on record came from a frightened man. Most of us were taught that calm means not feeling it, or at least never letting it show. He felt all of it, and 155 people went home.

Two things that look the same

Ask a room of leaders what calm under pressure looks like and most will describe a face. A level voice and nothing given away.

That is one way to do it. Psychologists call it suppression. The feeling arrives at full strength and you put a lid on it. Everything is still going on underneath, and part of your attention now has a second job holding the lid down.

The other way starts earlier. Before the feeling peaks, you change what the event means. The late report stops being an insult and becomes information about a handover that broke. Psychologists call this reappraisal. The feeling that follows is smaller, so there is less to hide.

From across the table you cannot tell them apart. The research can.

The lidThe reframe
What you doHide the feeling after it has arrivedChange what the event means before the feeling peaks
The feeling itselfStays, and in one study got worseShrinks
Your memory of the conversationWorseAs good, and in one study better
The other personBigger rise in blood pressure, less rapportNo such cost found
Where it fitsA short emergency with no time to thinkAnything that will happen again
What it asks of youEffort for as long as it is onPractice, and catching the moment early

From Richards and Gross 2000, Richards, Butler and Gross 2003, and Butler and colleagues 2003. All three are laboratory studies.

What the lid costs you

In 2000 Jane Richards and James Gross at Stanford showed people upsetting films and slides. Some were told to hide any reaction. Afterwards that group remembered fewer details of what they had seen. A group told to reframe what they were watching remembered as much as people who were left alone.

Three years later the same researchers, with Emily Butler, moved from films to something closer to life. Dating couples sat down to discuss a real disagreement. The partner told to conceal their feelings remembered less of what was said. The partner told to reframe remembered more.

Put that in your own diary. A resignation, or a month that missed by a distance. These are the conversations where the detail matters most, and they are the ones where the lid takes part of your hearing. You walk out looking composed and missing some of what you were told.

What it costs the person opposite

A second 2003 study, led by Butler, paired women who had never met and asked them to talk through an upsetting topic. One of each pair had been quietly told to show no emotion at all. Her partner knew nothing about the instruction.

The partner’s blood pressure rose more than it did in pairs where both women behaved naturally or where one reframed. In a second experiment it rose in both women. The partners also reported less rapport with the woman holding the lid, and less interest in getting to know her.

So the poker face does not protect the room. The other person can tell something is being held back, and their body braces for it.

Then you take the same face home. In DDI’s 2025 survey of 10,796 leaders, 71 in 100 said their stress had climbed sharply since they took their current role. For many of them the lid goes on at the first meeting and is still on at dinner.

The couples study was about that dinner. If someone you love has told you that you never listen, on an evening when you were sure you were being admirably calm, the lab has an explanation.

How far the evidence goes

These are laboratory studies and they are more than twenty years old. The strangers in Butler’s experiments were all women. Nobody has run the test on a regional director in budget week, so the size of the cost inside a real management team is unknown.

The lid also has its place. With three and a half minutes and no engines, nobody should stop to reframe the geese.

And showing some feeling in public does less harm than leaders fear. In 2009 Juan Madera and Brent Smith asked people to judge leaders responding to a company crisis. Leaders who showed sadness, or sadness alongside anger, were rated above those who showed anger alone. A feeling that fitted the facts did not cost them credibility.

Calm is built before it is needed

Back to the cockpit. Sullenberger told CBS that his body’s reaction was strong and that he had to make himself use his training. He said it took concentration. He had been flying for 42 years.

The handover of control is a two word call that every crew rehearses. The checklist exists so that nobody has to invent it at 2,800 feet. His attention had somewhere to go.

Researchers who work on mental fitness make the same point with less drama. In 2015 a panel of 25 specialists led by Paula Robinson agreed a definition that opens with the words “modifiable capacity”. Modifiable is the word to keep. It puts composure in the same category as a squat or a 5K time, something you build by repetition before the day you need it.

Amishi Jha’s lab at the University of Miami has tested how much repetition. In a 2019 study with elite military personnel, the group that trained for four weeks with daily practice did better on tests of attention and working memory than groups that trained for two weeks or not at all. Jha’s working floor is about 12 minutes a day.

That is attention training in a military setting. Nobody has shown it improves a P&L review. It does show that the capacity moves with practice, and that a fortnight is too short.

Your team gets the benefit. In 2025 James Donald and colleagues pooled 109 studies covering close to 20,000 people. Leaders who scored higher on steady, undefensive attention had teams reporting better relationships with them, higher wellbeing and better performance. Most of those studies are snapshots, so read it as a consistent pattern and stop short of calling it cause.

The next piece of bad news

Some time this week somebody will bring you something you did not want to hear. You will have a couple of seconds and two options.

The first is the lid. It is quick and it works for a short emergency. Use it when there is truly no time, and take it off when the emergency is over.

The second starts with a question you ask yourself before you answer them. What else could this mean? A late report might mean a careless manager. It might mean a manager who has been covering two jobs since March. You do not have to believe the kinder reading. You only have to consider it, and the feeling arrives at a size you can work with.

Then say one plain sentence about where you are. “That is not what I hoped to hear. Walk me through it.” People settle faster when they know what they are dealing with.

Both options keep your face steady. The first costs you part of the conversation and passes some of the strain across the table. The second leaves you with the details and leaves the other person’s blood pressure alone.

Find out what keeps putting you under it

If the lid is on for most of your day, the useful question is what keeps the pressure coming. The diagnostic is a free, confidential 30 minute call. We work through four layers of your situation (Clarity, Leadership, People and Engine) and name the first place it breaks. You leave with that constraint named and a first move.

Book my diagnostic

References

The figures above are translated from these sources. Percentages are written as people in 100.

  1. National Transportation Safety Board (2010). Loss of Thrust in Both Engines After Encountering a Flock of Birds and Subsequent Ditching on the Hudson River, US Airways Flight 1549, 15 January 2009. Accident Report AAR-10/03. 150 passengers and 5 crew, all survived. Cockpit voice recorder and air traffic transcripts released by the NTSB and FAA, February and June 2009.
  2. CBS News, 60 Minutes (8 February 2009). Chesley Sullenberger interviewed by Katie Couric. ESPN interview with Rick Reilly, reported by the Associated Press, February 2009.
  3. Richards, J. M. and Gross, J. J. (2000). Emotion regulation and memory: the cognitive costs of keeping one’s cool. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79(3), 410 to 424. Three studies. Suppression reduced memory for film and slide details. Reappraisal did not.
  4. Richards, J. M., Butler, E. A. and Gross, J. J. (2003). Emotion regulation in romantic relationships: the cognitive consequences of concealing feelings. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 20(5), 599 to 620. Dating couples, conflict discussion, random assignment. Memory for conversation utterances increased by reappraisal and decreased by suppression.
  5. Butler, E. A., Egloff, B., Wilhelm, F. H., Smith, N. C., Erickson, E. A. and Gross, J. J. (2003). The social consequences of expressive suppression. Emotion, 3(1), 48 to 67. Two studies, unacquainted pairs of women. Study 1: suppression disrupted communication and magnified blood pressure responses in partners. Study 2: blood pressure increased in both regulators and partners, with a negative effect on the regulator’s emotional experience. Reduced rapport and relationship formation.
  6. DDI (2025). Global Leadership Forecast 2025. 10,796 leaders and 2,185 HR professionals. 71% of leaders report a significant increase in stress since stepping into their current role, up from 63% in 2022.
  7. Madera, J. M. and Smith, D. B. (2009). The effects of leader negative emotions on evaluations of leadership in a crisis situation: the role of anger and sadness. The Leadership Quarterly, 20.
  8. Robinson, P., Oades, L. G. and Caputi, P. (2015). Conceptualising and measuring mental fitness: a Delphi study. International Journal of Wellbeing, 5(1), 53 to 73. International expert panel, n = 25.
  9. Zanesco, A. P., Denkova, E., Rogers, S. L., MacNulty, W. K. and Jha, A. P. (2019). Mindfulness training as cognitive training in high-demand cohorts: an initial study in elite military servicemembers. Progress in Brain Research, 244. Eight hour programme delivered over two or four weeks, against a no-training control. The 12 minute figure is Jha’s own published summary of her lab’s dose findings (Peak Mind, 2021).
  10. Donald, J. N., Nguyen, H., Conigrave, J. H. and colleagues (2025). Does leaders’ mindfulness benefit followers? A meta-analytic review and research agenda. British Journal of Management. 109 studies, 396 effect sizes, 19,887 participants. Moderate positive associations with follower-centred leadership, follower wellbeing, performance and leader and follower relations. Most included studies are cross-sectional.

Russell

Russell D & Associates

Executive Coaching & Consultancy

The Performance Brief is a weekly letter from Russell D & Associates for people who run clubs, teams and businesses.

russelldassociates.com


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *